council-book
PAPER · NO BROKER

Agents / Swing book

Bull · swing LLM

Argues for the swing ideas the Skeptic let through, claim by claim, citing the fact card.

Latest: made no claim → no swing trade; closest was TSLA long, stopped at PM (the manager passed)

PAPER Decision #3

Its last 3 meetings, newest first

  1. #31 of 1 reply unusable
  2. #2manager voted to enter NVCR long
  3. #1manager voted to enter MU long, NVCR long

✓ the manager voted to enter an idea it argued for · ✗ the manager passed on all of them

Its job

The same seat as the core bull, run on the swing ideas of a slot in one batch. It has no authority: the swing manager decides.

Kind
a language model; it never places an order
Prompt
prompts/swing_bull.md in force: council-swing_bull/v1 407e5420ec75

The same seat in the core council: its core page.

The swing book · the swing rules

Its numbers

Usable replies
2 of 3 calls
Calls by kind
3 paper
0 live · 0 rehearsal · in 3 meetings
Median time
4.2 s
per call

Failed calls

History

One entry per paper decision, newest first; the latest is open. Each idea links to its journey card on the decision page.

#3 · 2 Oct 2026, 14:40 UTC PAPER 1 of 1 reply unusable made no claim

Open decision #3 → · NO TRADE no swing trade; closest was TSLA long, stopped at PM (the manager passed)

#2 · 1 Oct 2026, 18:40 UTC PAPER manager voted to enter NVCR long argued for NVCR long, PLMK long, LRHC long

Open decision #2 → · NO TRADE no swing trade; closest was NVCR long, stopped at Rules (too little trading volume)

Three ideas survive on the same logic: hard, dated, company-specific catalysts disclosed hours ago with no completed session to price them. idea:2 is the cleanest — a national regulator (Japan MHLW) approved Optune Pax for unresectable locally advanced pancreatic cancer, a named new indication in a market NVCR did not serve. The Skeptic passed it. Reaction is flat: close sigma redacted live redacted, move vs sector redacted so there is no chase and no adverse stock-specific move. idea:5 is a wait, not a reject: the 8-K confirms convertible debt converting to equity at close plus a planned PIPE ahead of a Nasdaq listing, and the live move is only redacted with the stock in an uptrend (20-day return redacted, 60-day return redacted). idea:4 I concede: redacted (redacted) on the news day with XLF/SPX/NDX flat is a stock-specific rejection of the deal, and I will not fight it. I would take idea:2 and idea:5 at reduced size, skip idea:4, and keep the swing budget at redacted given the flat tape.

  1. c1 NVCR long: Japan MHLW approval of Optune Pax for unresectable locally advanced pancreatic cancer is a hard, new regulatory catalyst, disclosed 0.24 days ago.
  2. c2 NVCR long: The market has not moved on it: close sigma redacted live redacted, relative move redacted so entry is not chasing a spike.
  3. c3 NVCR long: Positioning is supportive: redacted of float short, redacted, and the stock sits redacted below its 52-week high.
  4. c4 NVCR long: The Skeptic passed the idea with no flags, and the approval text matches the claim exactly.
  5. c5 PLMK long: The 8-K confirms convertible debt converting to equity at close plus a planned PIPE ahead of a proposed Nasdaq listing — a multi-session capital-structure catalyst.
  6. c6 PLMK long: The adverse reaction is small: live redacted, close sigma redacted and the trend is up with 20-day return redacted and 60-day return redacted.
  7. c7 PLMK long: Volume ratio redactedon the news day is real attention, not a dead tape; the stock is only redacted below its 52-week high.
  8. c8 LRHC long: I concede idea:4: redacted (redacted) on the news day with XLF, SPX and NDX all flat is a stock-specific rejection, not beta.
#1 · 1 Oct 2026, 14:40 UTC PAPER manager voted to enter MU long, NVCR long argued for NVCR long, MU long, SINT long

Open decision #1 → · NO TRADE no swing trade; closest was NVCR long, stopped at Rules (too little trading volume)

The strongest honest case is idea:3 NVCR, then idea:1 MU. NVCR: the Japan MHLW approval is a genuinely new fact (filing age redacted, news age redacted) and the tape has not absorbed it — move since the news (σ) redacted live move only redacted (redacted) on redacted volume, with move vs sector redacted against flat SPX/sector. Short interest is redacted of float with redacted days to cover, so a squeeze tailwind sits behind a long, and the stock is redacted below its 52-week high with 20-day return redacted, i.e. the approval lands on a washed-out base rather than after a run. MU: the beat and strong guidance are hours old (news age redacted), the completed-bar move is exactly redacted (move since the news (σ) redacted), and the live drift is redacted (redacted) — a mild fade, not a rejection, on redacted volume, with trend up and 20-day return redacted. I concede idea:2 SINT: the Skeptic is right — redacted (redacted) on redacted volume on the day of the beat, after redacted in redacted sessions, is a stock-specific rejection with no squeeze fuel (redacted of float). I concede idea:5 JBL: the cited item is a preview, not results, and redacted on redacted volume with trend down is a fully expressed move against a long.

  1. c1 NVCR long: The Japan approval is hours old and unpriced: completed-bar move redacted, live move only redacted on redacted volume.
  2. c2 NVCR long: The move would be stock-specific: relative move 0 with SPX and sector flat over the window.
  3. c3 NVCR long: redacted of float short with redacted gives a squeeze tailwind behind a long.
  4. c4 NVCR long: The approval lands on a washed-out base: redacted below the 52-week high, 20-day return redacted, 60-day return redacted.
  5. c5 MU long: MU's completed-bar reaction to the beat is exactly zero, so the repricing has not shown up in bars yet.
  6. c6 MU long: The live fade is mild, not a rejection: redacted (redacted) on redacted volume, well inside a redacted ATR.
  7. c7 MU long: Trend is up with 20-day return redacted and 60-day return redacted, and the name is redacted below its 52-week high.
  8. c8 SINT long: Conceded: SINT fell redacted (redacted) on redacted volume on the beat day after redacted in redacted sessions, with only redacted of float short.